Made From Scratch.
Baked With Love.

Hershey's most-loved cookie company, right here on Chocolate Avenue.
Choose your flavors. Build your box. Pick up fresh.
Made From Scratch
Every batch, every day --
no mixes, no shortcuts
Fresh to Order
Baked the day you order --
guaranteed fresh
Pickup or Shipped
Grab yours in Hershey or
get USPS delivery
Community First
Hershey-made, Hershey-proud,
since 2025

Best Sellers

The ones everyone keeps coming back for

Chocolate Ave Chip

Our signature scratch-made dough loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chips in every bite. The one that started it all and still one of our most-loved cookies. Simple, perfect, and impossible to stop at one.

PB after Dark

Deep unsweetened cocoa swirled into our signature dough, loaded with peanut butter chips and finished with a peanut butter drizzle. Dark, rich, and intensely flavored.

Campfire S’mores

Everything you love about a s’more baked into our signature dough. Graham crackers, toasted marshmallows, and real chocolate bar pieces. Tastes like summer nights around the fire.

Sticky Apple

Real Honeycrisp apple pieces tossed in graham cracker crumbs, cinnamon, and sugar, folded into our signature dough and finished with a caramel drizzle. Sweet and completely irresistible.

Strawberry Crunch

Homemade strawberry cream spread across our signature dough, topped with strawberry shortcake crunch pieces. Bright, sweet, and totally craveable.

Downtown Duo

Cannot choose between chocolate and peanut butter? You do not have to. The Downtown Duo layers both chips into our signature dough for a cookie that hits every note. Rich, indulgent, and always a crowd favorite.

Pretty in Pearls

Smooth homemade vanilla cream frosting finished with crispy sugar pearls that add a satisfying crunch. Beautiful enough for a gift, delicious enough to keep for yourself.

What-EVs

When you cannot pick just one mix-in, you get the What-EVs. Oreo pieces, mini M&Ms, pretzels, sprinkles, and semi-sweet chocolate chips all piled into our signature dough. Chaotic, delicious, unapologetic.

Snap Crack PB Pop

Reeses peanut butter chips are topped with homemade marshmallow fluff and a generous layer of Rice Krispies for a cookie that snaps, crackles, and pops in every bite. Sweet, salty, and satisfyingly crunchy — this one is impossible to put down.

Ordering Is Easy

Step 1: Choose Your Box:
Half Dozen (6) or Full Dozen (12)

Step 2: Pick Your Flavors:
Mix and match from daily and special order flavors

Step 3: Pick Up Fresh:
Grab your box at 108 W Chocolate Avenue, Hershey PA or select USPS delivery

Raise Funds
the Sweet Way

Looking for a fundraiser your supporters will actually be excited about? Our cookie fundraiser program puts $1 from every cookie sold back into your organization. No upfront costs, no inventory to manage, and no convincing required. Cookies sell themselves. Whether you're raising money for a school, sports team, church, or community group, we make it simple to run a campaign your supporters will look forward to every time.

Made From Scratch in the Heart of Downtown Hershey

We started Hershey Cookie Company with one simple belief: everyone deserves a really good cookie. Using our signature scratch-made dough and the finest toppings, we craft every batch by hand, because shortcuts have no place in our kitchen.

Find us daily at 108 W Chocolate Avenue inside Stuff'D Steaks & Hoagies, pre-order your favorites online, or ask about carrying our cookies at your business.

Don't Take Our Word for It

We're humbled every day by the kind words from our Downtown Hershey community.